Cuts to Mental Health Crisis Care
New Script Demands Answers – Where Are People in Crisis Supposed to Turn?
New Script for Mental Health has raised serious concerns about two changes to mental health services in recent days - the rollout of Right Care, Right Person (RCRP) across Northern Ireland and the Western Health and Social Care Trust’s decision to remove the Card Before You Leave (CBYL) scheme for young people experiencing distress. Coming against a backdrop of dangerously long waits for mental health assessment and support and the failure to adequately fund mental health services, these developments raise urgent questions about whether people in crisis are being left with even less support than before.
The PSNI’s introduction of RCRP, which means that the PSNI will no longer be responding to ‘concerns for safety’ calls, unless there is a real or immediate risk to life or serious harm, comes against a backdrop of longstanding failures to adequately fund and transform mental health services. The Department of Health’s Mental Health Strategy 2021–2031 promised to ensure people could access the right support at the right time, through accessible, person-centred, and trauma-informed services, with a focus on prevention, early intervention, and recovery.
Yet the Department’s own review found that by the end of 2024/25, only 16% of the funding deemed necessary for implementation had been allocated. The Strategy’s ambition to make mental health services fit for purpose remains largely unrealised, with people continuing to face long waits for assessment, treatment, and support.
New Script supports the principle that people experiencing mental health distress should receive appropriate support from health and social care services rather than defaulting to PSNI involvement. But changing who responds to a crisis does not create the services people need.
This evidence from NHS England underlines the need for robust safeguards and proper scrutiny. People must not be left waiting, passed between services, or abandoned because the service best placed to help them is unavailable.
There is no evidence that mental health services are sufficiently developed, resourced and accessible to respond to people who will no longer receive a police response under RCRP. A rapid process review of RCRP in England in 2024 found that while it did reduce police involvement, it did not establish that people experiencing mental health crisis received better or more timely care. It identified health and social care capacity as the main barrier to implementation. This evidence from NHS England underlines the need for robust safeguards and proper scrutiny. People must not be left waiting, passed between services, or abandoned because the service best placed to help them is unavailable.
Concerns have also emerged about the Western Health and Social Care Trust’s decision to cut the Card Before You Leave scheme ( CBYL) for young people experiencing significant distress. New Script for Mental Health has submitted an FOI to the Western Trust seeking information on how this decision was made and how potential risk and harm to young people experiencing distress will be prevented.
The CBYL scheme was introduced following a successful campaign by families bereaved by suicide, supported by Participation and the Practice of Rights (PPR). These families knew, through devastating personal experience, what was needed to help prevent further deaths. They were determined to ensure that other families would not lose loved ones to preventable deaths.
Their campaign helped secure a practical intervention intended to provide people with a timely route to support when they were experiencing distress. The decision now to remove the scheme raises serious questions about how the experiences and expertise of families with first-hand experience are being valued, what risk assessment was undertaken and what alternative support is now available. At a time when young people are already facing significant barriers to accessing mental health services, the removal of an established support mechanism is deeply concerning.
Kirsty Scott, New Script activist who campaigned for the introduction of Care Before You Leave expressed her deep distress at hearing that this service is being axed:
“I was part of the campaign to have Card Before You Leave introduced across the five Health and Social Care Trusts in 2010. My reason for getting involved was deeply personal. I lost my 19-year-old son, William, because of failures in mental health services. My family and I did not want any other family to endure the grief and pain we continue to live with, or to lose a loved one to a preventable death.
To find out that this vital support for young people has now been cut is deeply distressing. The Western Trust must urgently explain what risk assessment it conducted before making this decision, and how it will ensure the safety and wellbeing of young people who may now be left without support, particularly over weekends.
As families who have experienced the devastating consequences of failures in mental health services, we should never have had to campaign for the basic support young people need. We fought to ensure that other families would not experience the loss we have suffered. We are not prepared to see vital services like Card Before You Leave stripped away, without any evidence that alternative, timely and accessible services are in place for the increasing numbers of young people in distress.
The Trust must listen to the families who know, through lived experience, what is at stake. It must explain how it will prevent young people from being left without help when they are at their most vulnerable.”
Taken together, the rollout of RCRP, the removal of CBYL, long waits for support and the failure to adequately fund the Mental Health Strategy all point to a worrying pattern: changes to how people experiencing mental health distress are supported, without clear evidence that adequate alternatives are in place.
New Script is calling on the Department of Health, the PSNI and Health and Social Care Trusts to urgently publish the evidence underpinning these decisions, demonstrate that appropriate services and safeguards are in place, and ensure that people experiencing mental health crisis are not left without the support they need.